Seniors
1. Izzy Lee (Illinois)
2. Victoria Safradin (Virginia)
3. Annabel Austen (USC)
4. Olivia Shippee (Boston College)
5. Keara Fitzgerald (Washington State)
6. Aubrey Brown (SMU)
7. Kate Phillips (Missouri)
8. Nona Reason (Clemson)
9. Ellie Goodrich (Old Dominion)
10. Sarah Wommack (Mississippi State)
11. Jayden Emmanuel (Florida)
12. Mallorie Benhart (South Dakota State)
13. Audur Scheving (LSU, Iceland)
14. Olivia Bodmer (Rutgers)
15. Jordan Brown (Georgia)
16. Atlee Olofson (Miami)
17. Jackie Hollomon (Notre Dame)
Storylines to Watch: The senior class is filled with goalkeepers looking to prove themselves as they either aim to finish on a strong note or propel themselves forward into the professional ranks. Fitzgerald and Brown are returning from injuries that derailed their 2025 seasons and while it’s clear both have plenty of gas left in the tank, questions will always surface about how quickly they can return to 100%.
Goalkeepers familiar with the transfer portal like Wommack (Appalachian State), Reason (UNC), and Olofson (Notre Dame) have yet to have that great season that shows why they transferred in the first place and now former Penn goalkeeper Annabel Austen joins the group as she headed west to join USC.
For goalkeepers like Brown, Emmanuel, and Bodmer, it’s been a lot of peaks and valleys so far in their collegiate careers. The question isn’t about the ceiling, which is high for each of them, but more about finding consistency as a great goalkeeper, not one who happens to find great moments every now and then.
All-American front runners have to include Lee and Safradin, both of whom spent time training with Racing Louisville this summer. The two are not only some of the more rounded out goalkeepers in the collegiate ranks, but their ability to make the game-saving action puts them in their own category.
There’s still a lot left to fight for in 2026 and the senior group should provide weekly highlights to thrill USWNT fans of upcoming prospects.
Juniors
1. Liv Geller (TCU)
2. Sonoma Kasica (Notre Dame)
3. Caroline Dysart (Duke)
4. Keegan Smith (Arkansas)
5. Valentina Amaral (Wake Forest)
6. Sarah Martin (Minnesota)
7. Mariangela Medina (UCLA, Mexico)
8. Cameron Gabrielson (Georgetown)
9. Nimu Karani (St. Louis)
10. Paloma Pena Toro (Florida, Dominican Republic)
11. Sammy Widnick (La Salle)
12. Kaiya Jota (Stanford)
13. Aris Lamanna (Coastal Carolina)
14. Sydney Fuller (Texas A&M)
15. Kennadie Marchand (Vanderbilt)
16. Jamie Campbell (Colorado)
17. Addie Todd (Texas Tech)
Storylines to Watch: The junior class enters 2026 largely trying to get the taste of 2025 out of their mouth. Very few of the top juniors notched the majority of their team’s minutes with their schools last season. Lamanna and Smith are returning from injuries, whereas exciting prospects like Medina, Gabrielson, Karani, Jota, Fuller, Marchand, and Campbell barely saw the field last season, despite clearly having the ability to play at the D1 level.
And looking at our top goalkeepers, they all had sour endings to 2025 and are certainly looking to finish on a stronger note in 2026. Whether it’s Geller mishandling a bouncing shot on frame against Florida State… or Kasica misplaying a cross in double overtime against Ohio State… or Dysart getting a better jump on the free kick against Stanford… or Amaral getting a strong hand against the looping shot from Michigan State… or Sarah Martin and Minnesota not being especially close to seeing even just the conference tournament… the juniors are likely looking forward to 2026 more than the other three classes.
Sophomores
1. Kate Ockene (Florida State)
2. Noe Henning (Michigan State, Canada)
3. Emilie Maihs (Kentucky, Germany)
4. Lexi Baldwin (Iowa)
5. Caroline Birkel (Stanford)
6. Molly Vapensky (Duke)
7. Hannah Folliard (Georgia)
8. Daphne Nakfoor (UCLA)
9. Charlotte Wilfert (UC San Diego)
10. Brooke Goerish (Colorado)
11. Tyra Bengtsson-Stenseth (San Francisco, Norway)
12. Mateya Dessieux (Texas)
13. Sienna Smart (Mississippi)
14. Brooklynn Harding (Illinois State)
15. Kennedy Zorn (Arizona State)
16. Pepper Escher (St. Louis)
17. Grace Shoemaker (High Point)
18. Chase Rooney (Virginia Tech)
19. Gianna Mlynek (Xavier)
20. Kaele Smith (NJIT)
Storylines to Watch: Unlike the junior class, the sophomores are looking to use 2025 as a positive stepping stone. Henning survived a tough goalkeeping battle with Zorn, although the latter has already found a new home to continue to build out her collegiate resume. And for other goalkeeping battles, Baldwin, Folliard, Nakfoor, and Goerish are all more than aware that their school has another top goalkeeper on their respective roster (scroll up or down to see who). It’s not a matter of having talent, but rather being able to create more winning moments for their team than their teammate can.
Goalkeepers like Vapensky, Smart, Harding, Shoemaker, Rooney, Mlynek, and Smith were largely off the radar in 2025 but all should make some noise this year, barring an untimely injury.
And although Wilfert was the surprise for 2025, going from relative unknown to a top prospect in her class, it’s Ockene who really left her stamp on the scene. Ockene’s nine-save shutout in the final against Stanford marked the highest profile goalkeeping moment in women’s college soccer since Katie Meyer’s 2019 penalty shootout heroics.
Unlike the other classes, just because someone’s not at the top of the list doesn’t mean they don’t have pro potential. The sophomore class is stacked and more goalkeepers who didn’t make the cut here will surely surface down the line to make a name for themselves.
First Years
1. Ella Wiederaenders (Tennessee)
2. Madelyn Macdonald (Georgetown)
3. Peyton Trayer (North Carolina)
4. Braelynn Galt (Iowa, Scotland)
5. Isabel Willems (Yale)
6. Natalie Cohen (Virginia)
7. Emeline McClenahan (Iowa State)
8. Wicki Dunlap (Virginia)
9. Malia Zillman (Michigan)
10. Lily Selvy (Penn State)
11. Ella Moersch (Iowa State)
12. Lizzie Thornton (Wake Forest)
13. London Phoenix (UNC Asheville, Jamaica)
Storylines to Watch: Preseason rankings for first years are always a crapshoot but these thirteen here - and there are more to come - are yet another stepping stone in women’s goalkeeper development. The general athletic level and tactical understanding of the position have skyrocketed from just ten years ago. The early part of the century didn’t see schools recruiting the program’s best goalkeepers they’ve ever had as even smaller schools are able to find young goalkeepers who can cover more and more of the goalframe.
It’s much too early to say anything of real substance for these goalkeepers other than the new “5 for 5” rule should pave an easier pathway for these goalkeepers to get minutes, if they’re anywhere near ready to play. No longer do goalkeepers have to sit a year to preserve a redshirt and even a 45 minute spell can be a significant vote of confidence in knowing where first years stand in the school’s long-term plans.
Past Collegiate Goalkeeper Rankings
2025: Preseason and Final
2024: Preseason and Final
2023: Preseason and Final
2022: Preseason and Final
2021: Preseason and Final
2020: Preseason and Final
2019: Preseason and Final
2018: Preseason and Final
2017: Preseason and Final
2016: Preseason and Final
2015: Preseason and Final