Hope Solo vs. Norway - 03.04.15

It's unlikely there will be a game recap for Switzerland and Iceland but Solo made some interesting decisions against Norway that deserved a closer look.

In the fourth minute, a floated cross drops in. Solo runs out to collect, a decision that isn't right or wrong in itself. If she handles it well, then great, but there are enough numbers back that the risk in one option over the other is negligible. However, the argument is void because Solo lets the ball go through her hands.

The collision is distracting but not an excuse for poor technique to creep in. If anything, she should have fumbled the ball forward because her hands were too close. The ball is cleared out without harm but it should be remembered for her defense, as well as opposing offenses looking to score.

Norway takes a 1-0 lead before halftime in the 43rd minute that features another crossing situation for Solo.

Halfway through the cross, Solo correctly skips ahead with her eyes (second frame). She has a good angle of the upcoming header but her feet are a mess. The next frame shows her left foot on the ground but her right still descending. As the ball encroaches the goal, her one planted foot cannot jump because the other is coming down. Once her right foot is finally on the ground, the ball is a foot from the net and she can't get enough leverage to push the ball over the crossbar. She only leaves the ground after the ball has been scored. If she sorts out her jumpset, she can make the save with ease.

Her final notable participation came nine minutes into the second half where a shot results out of a scrum in front of the goal. Solo palms away the tenseful moment.

Most were quick to praise her goal line save but if she had conceded a goal it would have been on her shoulders. This is a save she is expected to make. It's close to the body and at an angle that the shot location is limited. Moreover, the reason she makes the save is not because she moved her hands to the ball but because she dropped her knees instead. Her hands actually move away from where the ball is going at first. Look at the difference between the first and second frame, her hands instinctively jut upwards and her wrists start to turn over. She gets back down for the ball because her knees buckle. Her left knee is actually still in the way, which is why she doesn't collapse to the ground. Ideally, she maintains her shape as the ball is struck and either kicks her right leg away from the ball to give room for her hand or makes the skatesave.

Granted, these three plays are a veteran plays. And, yes, a save is a save but Solo's mechanics are slow to react. As she approaches thirty-four, she will either start over-relying on her slowing reactions or rightfully trusting in sound technique. Switzerland and Iceland will not be as tough as a test but the USWNT goalkeeper situation raises an eyebrow with the World Cup on the horizon. Ashlyn Harris and Alyssa Naeher may need to be given a closer look.

US Women's National Team Goalkeeper Pool - March 2015

Welcome to the first Women's Top 50! The World Cup less than 100 days away and if unless you haven't been on Twitter you know all about the buzz surrounding Hope Solo's return to the USWNT. While Solo is the expected starter, there should be little worry if Ashlyn Harris were to fill in. Yes, she was in goal for the 2-0 loss against France, but she's playing sharp and the goals would have been scored on any of the goalkeepers listed below, not to mention that Harris kept the score at only two. Along that line, there are plenty of goalkeepers that could fill in for Solo if it were to come for it.

Five other goalkeepers you should take note of:

  1. Mallori Lofton - She is still recovering from concussion symptoms but if she can regain her form, she'll contend for the starting spot following this World Cup. (Highlights)
  2. Michelle Betos - Betos is in an interesting position sitting behind the most recent FIFA Women's Play of the Year winner, Nadine Angerer. Angerer is 36 years old while Betos, 27, is entering her prime. We could see a switch at the guard in Portland soon. (Highlights)
  3. Libby Stout - The starting goalkeeper for Liverpool at only 24, Stout led the team to winning the FA WSL - the highest league in England - and reached the Round of 32 in the Champions League. (Highlights)
  4. Katie Fraine - Coincidentally, Stout's run in the Champions League was ended by Linkoping. Fraine and Linkoping have reached the quarterfinals and play Brøndby on the 22nd and 28th for a shot in the semifinal. (Highlights)
  5. Sabrina D'Angelo - D'Angelo was drafted this year by goalkeeper-heavy Western NY. She may be off the radar for a few years as she develops but could definitely take over the starting spot when the time comes. (Highlights)

The USWNT returns to the Algarve Cup this year, playing their first game against Norway on Wednesday. The World Cup kicks off June 6th.

I've researched as much as I could on each goalkeeper but as you can guess some were easier to find footage and recent information on than others. Each line includes the player's name, their club, overall rating, and their age. For a guide on ratings, over 58 is an elite goalkeeper. 58 to 56 is an above average professional starter while below 56 is sub-average. If you are aware of any inaccuracies, please, for all things goalkeeper, inform me of my mistake.

1. Ashlyn Harris (Washington Spirit / USA.1) - 57.9 (29.4)
2. Hope Solo (Seattle Reign / USA.1) - 57.7 (33.7)
3. Mallori Lofton (SC Sand / Germany.1) - 57.6 (27.5)
4. Nicole Barnhart (FC Kansas City / USA.1) - 57.4 (33.4)
5. Michelle Betos (Portland Thorns FC / USA.1) - 57.4 (27.1)
6. Alyssa Naeher (Boston Breakers / USA.1) - 57.3 (26.9)
7. Ashley Thompson (Medkila / Norway.1) - 57.2 (29.2)
8. Libby Stout (Liverpool / England.1) - 57.1 (24.8)
9. Katie Fraine (Linkoping / Sweden.1) - 57.1 (27.3)
10. Brittany Cameron (Sky Blue FC / USA.1) - 57.1 (28.3)

11. Arianna Criscione (Saint-Étienne / France.1) - 56.5 (30.1)
12. Michele Dalton (Kvarnsveden / Sweden.2) - 56.3 (26.8)
13. Adelaide Gay (Washington Spirit / USA.1) - 56.3 (25.3)
14. Alyssa Whitehead (Mallbacken / Sweden.1) - 56.2 (25.3)
15. Allysa Clark (Masinac Nis / Serbia.1) - 56.1 (28.5)
16. Chantel Jones (Washington Spirit / USA.1) - 56.1 (26.7)
17. Catherine Fitzsimmons (ASPTT Albi / France.1) - 56 (26.3)
18. Jeannette Williams (Vikingur Olafsvik / Iceland.2) - 55.7 (26.2)
19. Jaime Souza (Arna-Bjørnar / Norway.1) - 55.5 (29.2)
20. Bianca Henninger (Houston Dash / USA.1) - 55.4 (24.4)

21. Vikki Alonzo (Thor / KA / Iceland.1) - 55.2 (25.2)
22. Adrianna Franch (Western New York Flash / USA.1) - 55.2 (24.3)
23. Chanté Sandiford (Free Agent / None) - 55 (25.2)
24. Brett Maron (Kristianstad / Sweden.1) - 55 (28.8)
25. Alexa Gaul (Selfoss / Iceland.1) - 54.8 (23.8)
26. Haley Kopmeyer (Seattle Reign / USA.1) - 54.8 (24.8)
27. Shelby Tomasello (Höttur / Iceland.2) - 54.5 (24.4)
28. Sara Keane (FC Kansas City / USA.1) - 54.1 (23.8)
29. Micaela Crowley (IR Reykjavik / Sweden.2) - 54 (30.2)
30. Dijana Haracic (Western New York Flash / USA.1) - 53.9 (23.2)

31. Aubrey Bledsoe (Sky Blue FC / USA.1) - 53.8 (23.3)
32. Meagan McCray (Valur / Iceland.1) - 53.7 (27.8)
33. Kelsey Wys (Western New York Flash / USA.1) - 53.7 (24.1)
34. Sarah Glass (Throttur Reykjavik / Sweden.2) - 53.5 (27.2)
35. Taylor Vancil (Chicago Red Stars / USA.1) - 53.4 (23.8)
36. Anna Sieloff (BV Cloppenburg / Germany.1) - 53.3 (22.9)
37. Katherine Linn (Issy / France.1) - 53.1 (23.2)
38. Brittany Anghel (AIK / Sweden.1) - 53.1 (22.6)
39. Caitlin Updyke (IA Akranes / Iceland.1) - 52.9 (22.8)
40. Jami Ann Kranich (Boston Breakers / USA.1) - 52.7 (22.8)

41. Megan Kinneman (Houston Dash / USA.1) - 52.4 (22.8)
42. Sabrina D'Angelo (Western New York Flash / USA.1) - 52.2 (21.8)
43. Caroline Stanley (USC / USA.N) - 51.6 (22)
43. Megan Kufeld (Washington / USA.N) - 51.6 (22)
45. Abby Smith (Texas / USA.N) - 51.1 (21.4)
46. Jordan Day (Free Agent / None) - 51 (21.9)
47. Abigail Steele (Oregon / USA.N) - 50.8 (21.5)
48. Bryane Heaberlin (North Carolina / USA.N) - 50.5 (21.3)
49. Holly Van Noord (Liberty / USA.N) - 50.5 (21.6)
50. Katelyn Rowland (FC Kansas City / USA.1) - 49.6 (21)

Phil Saunders Interview

Phil Saunders graduated from UMBC last spring and since then has been a standout for Icelandic side Bí/Bolungarvík. Facing relegation, Saunders tightened up the defense to stay afloat in the second division. Set to return in 2015 for his first full season with the club, Saunders talks about his time abroad and what it took to get there.

There’s some debate on if players should focus solely on soccer or play multi-sports. So looking back to when you were younger, what outside of soccer helped you become a good goalkeeper?

I actually played baseball my whole life. I played catcher and centerfield. I had to make a decision in 10th grade and I ended up choosing soccer. I was always told I was a better baseball player than a soccer player. But baseball helped with hand-eye coordination and tracking balls.

And why’d you choose soccer over baseball?

I just found it more interesting. You’re more involved. I know a lot of people say baseball can get boring and that was honestly the truth for me. I just enjoyed soccer more.

In 2009 you began your freshmen year at UMBC, where you started twenty games in goal for the Retrievers. Why’d you commit to UMBC and were there any other schools you were looking at?

I’ve lived in Baltimore my whole life so that definitely helped. I’ve known Peter Caringi, UMBC’s head coach, since I was probably eight years old. I went to his camps when I was younger. I got lucky, playing against his son, actually, and I must have had twenty saves but we still lost 4-0. I ended up playing on the Baltimore Bays with his son so he got to watch me play just about every game. I had offers from UMBC and Loyola. Knowing the coaching staff and a lot of the players at UMBC, I decided to go there.

You graduated from UMBC last year then signed in Iceland with Bí/Bolungarvík. Looking back, what advice would you give to a collegiate player trying to make the jump?

It sounds cliché but you have to keep going. You can’t give up. I went to two different combines... I went to the InfoSports combine and nothing came from that. Then I went to the NASL combine, nothing ended up coming from that. I was close to saying, “I went for it.” Then I went over to England and had a trial with Crewe Alexandra. I was there for a week and then that didn’t work out. I came back and was felt like, “Damn, where do I go from here?” I got an offer to go to another combine and figured I’d go for it. That’s when it all came about. I played well, found an agent that linked me up with a trail in Iceland, and it worked out. But the biggest thing is you can't give up. Every time you think, “That’s the end” there’s always something more if you want it.

That last soccer combine you went to, was that SoccerViza?

Yeah.

Do you think if that one didn’t work out then that would have ended it?

It definitely would have been a big hit. If something would have fallen in my lap or later down the line, I’m not saying I wouldn’t have gone for it but, let’s be real, it’s a lot of money going to these things. There’s a limit. I’m trying to stay in shape to pay for these combines. It’s tough.

So after spending a year in Iceland, how does American soccer compare to Icelandic?

It’s tough because I’ve never played professionally in America. I trained with DC United and that was… five years ago, so that was a long time ago. I think Iceland is more technical. It is pretty physical. The only thing they’re lacking that MLS has is that athleticism that everyone talks about. Technically, they’re a lot better than I thought it was going to be. I’m playing with Nigel Quashie. He’s done some stuff with the ball that I’ve seen before. Or even thought of doing.

On the athleticism, is that more of strength or endurance?

The speed. I wouldn’t say strength. You get some of those Icelandic guys that look like fisherman. Just big, big guys. But I think it’s mostly the speed. I remember watching a couple of Americans coming over to Iceland that had an edge when it came to speed.

What’s it like being American representative for people? How warm were you welcomed? And was there a question you were asked a lot?

I had an awesome experience last season. The guys over there were great. Everyone over there was really nice and laid back. They all knew English and were fluent so that helped a lot. I was a bit nervous going over there and not knowing the language at all. Of course, they all wanted to know how college was and the typical “Have you been to California or New York?” Those types of questions. But overall the guys were real nice. They were real accepting.

You hear a lot about players not feeling comfortable overseas and performing poorly. Then there are some that really thrive in it. So what, in your opinion, does it come down to for an American player to go to Europe and be successful?

You have to have a good team around you, not just on the field but outside of that. Luckily when I was there, everyone was really close. We all lived really close to each other so it was really easy to hang out. Like I said, they all know English, which was huge. I don’t know what it would be like if none or hardly any of my teammates knew English. The biggest thing for me was getting homesick. I got really homesick whenever I was over in England the first time and I was only there for a month. When I went over this last time, I felt comfortable. They all made me feel accepted and encouraged me. I couldn’t have had a better first pro season somewhere else.

You’re playing with an indoor team right now, the Baltimore Blast. Coming from outdoor, how does indoor help or hurt your game?

It definitely has helped my feet out a lot. There’s a lot of quick movement and also just on the ball. In indoor, you have the ball at your feet a lot. Indoor has made me one hundred times better with my feet. And obviously the reactions with shots.

I think that maybe the thing that hurts me a bit would be the technique because you don’t have time to focus on diving forward. It’s just reaction saves, kick saves, and diving backwards sometimes. But that’s all something that will come back once I get back to the big goal.

Last three questions: One, what’s the most important game you’ve played in?

Most important game? That’s tough… Probably my first game in Iceland. My first professional game. I had just signed that day. It was really quick when I got over there and I wanted to impress. They threw me into that first game so it could have been make or break. If I played bad, I could have been sitting for the rest of the year. But I went in, played well and it went really well, actually.

Following your season, that’s a little bit of an understatement. Do you have any pre-game rituals?

My dad passed away in 2011 so before every game I kneel at the post and say a few words to him. Other than that, not too much.

And lastly, what’s your dream scenario in five years?

Honestly, I’d love to come back to America and play. I know everyone wants to play in the big leagues in Europe, and obviously that would be amazing, but I feel more comfortable in America. I think it would be really cool to make it to an MLS club.

Penalty Save Percentage vs. Height

Cover photo of Matt Jordan belongs to Getty Images.
Matt Jordan is MLS's best penalty saver at an outstanding 41% save percentage.

I received an email last week asking about a goalkeeper's height playing a factor in penalty kicks.

 

Taylor Twellman at least twice during the College Cup Championship shootout suggested that UVA keeper Callie Brown's being 6'5" played a big role in the two UCLA penalty misses. Twellman said something like, "Brown's size alone will put greater pressure on the PK takers, and this alone could be a factor in what caused these UCLA players to miss these penalties, by overcompensating for his height." But I have never seen any statistical evidence of this factor. From what I have seen from just watching games, I can't say that such a height of goalkeeper factor seems to actually relate to the number of penalty shots that are missed. I'm not talking about penalties saved. Do you know of any goalkeeper stats comparing the size of the keeper to the number of penalty shots missed?

I found an article which provides some research on perception of goalkeepers' height impacting shots but this study doesn't include any actual stats based on real soccer games in real penalty situations. The article does include a link to a research abstract that the article claims provides information on "preliminary data suggesting that their findings are indeed applicable to real-life situations. However, when I read that abstract, I found no reference whatsoever to any "real life" soccer situations.

 

The short answer is no, I don't. Data for penalty shots missed is somewhere, I'm sure, but not at my fingertips. So while I don't have any information on goalkeepers' size affecting a shooter to completely miss the target, I can graph the size of MLS goalkeepers against their penalty save percentage.

Nick Rimando sits alone in the bottom right corner.

Nick Rimando sits alone in the bottom right corner.

Using the thirty-eight goalkeepers who have faced ten penalties in MLS action, which doesn't include penalty shootouts, there seems to be no correlation (.03667) between a goalkeeper's height and performance in goal. I would assume the reason is that the difference between a saved penalty versus a scored one is impacted more by the goalkeeper's decision, not length. We rarely see a goalkeeper miss a penalty because his arms weren't long enough but quite often we see a goalkeeper going the wrong direction.

As for missed shots specifically, you can use the same argument for why a large goalkeeper will influence a shooter to shoot wider (and miss the goal) as a smaller goalkeeper will shoot closer to frame, making the shot more likely to be saved. If he's smaller, perhaps the shooter doesn't shoot as wide, and the goalkeeper would have an easier time getting to the ball. On top of that, a shooter is typically not aiming just inside the goalpost. He has given himself room to err so if he does shoot wider because of the goalkeeper's height, it would actually be harder on that goalkeeper to make the save.

If you have any thoughts on the subject, either comment below or email me at everybodysoccer@yahoo.com.