Grading Hollywood's Goalkeepers

Everybody Soccer welcomes siblings Tim and Sarah Dobrowolski to the site. The Dobrowolskis have an accomplished goalkeeping family, with Tim entering his third year with Louisville City while Sarah is currently finishing her junior year at the University of Wisconsin-Parkside. Both goalkeeping siblings bring in years of experience on the field and in the theaters to help break down Hollywood's best goalkeepers. For more inquiries on goalkeeping in film, you can find Tim and Sarah online at @timdobro and @sarahdobro.

 

Bend It Like Beckham

Bill: I know what you’re thinking and yes, I completely agree, this is quite the damning advertisement for Umbro gloves. If flapping wildly at a shot hit straight down the middle of the goal isn’t enough to stop a shot that’s moving at two miles an hour, then I can’t imagine those gloves are worth anything. Aside from the glove malfunction, the goalkeeper should probably set up a better wall than one that is busy transforming into elderly women and back into baggily dressed soccer players. Grade: B-

Tim: I’m never one to complain about the style of goalkeeper jerseys throughout history, but man was that green a hideous color. Besides the fashion blunder, I had two issues with our goalkeeper. First, I don’t recall seeing any communication between the goalkeeper and her wall. Sometimes the environment will swallow up the goalkeeper’s voice, in this case it seemed to be overbearing opera music. Therefore the goalkeeper needs to use any method necessary. Second, it seemed as though the goalkeeper was just as shocked as our main character about the ever-transforming wall! Grade: C+

Sarah: Two things come to mind when I watch this clip, first is how poor the foul is. Was it truly deserving of a yellow card? I will give props to the actor for faking it pretty well though. The second thing that comes to mind is seeing the goalkeeper set up her wall clinging to her near post, and then watching her bat at the shot like a fly is about to buzz right into her mouth. Sub-par shot followed by sub-par goalkeeping. Although I would be terrified too if my Indian mothers and grandmothers were my hallucinated wall! Grade: C

 

Shaolin Soccer

Tim: Other than the disturbing lack of faith portrayed by many of the coaches and players, this clip shows strong determination and belief in oneself. The hand-eye coordination displayed by the goalkeeper is only attained by those who master the highest levels of clarity and transcendence. What I’m most impressed by is the flight of the counterattack ball. It had a near perfect spin and pace that allowed the forward to make a beautiful one-touch volley. Grade: A-

Sarah: I have never seen this movie, but man do I wish this was how soccer was played. This is the ultimate collaboration between soccer and Avatar the Last Airbender. The goalkeeper handled the shot with beauty and elegance. Starting with a foot save that was brought to the hands, she then turned to her teammate for a tactful counter-attack turned goal. For a bonus they shamed their opponent and their families by literally ripping their clothes off with the sheer power of the shot. Mention note: need to learn how to harvest the powers of the earth and teach it to the youngins. Grade: A+

Bill: I’ve always been a big fan of removing demonic possession from the game and this is a great example of a goalkeeper standing strong in the face of wicked demonry. So it’s nice to see a big corporation like Puma supporting the righteous cause. While a bit unconventional, the distribution is spot on and helps shed the blinders to what the other goalkeeper is: a lousy schmuck. Overall a strong performance but negative points for not using the W handshape for a hard shot on frame. Grade: B+

 

She’s the Man

Sarah: This is a classic soccer movie for any girl. The one thing that drives me nuts, besides the totally unrealistic planning of a second shot off of the goalkeeper save, is that Amanda is playing with her hair down. Any girl can relate that this is totally a pain in the ass and that there is no way she would last five minutes running around with it down. Goalkeeper-wise that was a great first save made by the defending goalkeeper, no less off of a penalty kick. Too bad he couldn’t recreate that save on the opposite side of the net! Just goes to show that girls rule and boys have cooties. Grade: A

Bill: The goalkeeper makes a great penalty save but follows it up with an awkward dive back to his right on the rebound. His shoulders are turned and he's basically skipping towards the post instead of laying out again. Unfortunately, Sarah is probably on to something with the goalkeeper’s high cootie content. It looks like it really held him back from committing to the save. Hopefully, the goalkeeper saw a doctor soon after to receive his vaccinations. Grade: B-

Tim: *Trying not to think about the crush I used to have on Amanda Bynes* I commend the goalkeeper for making a fine save on the initial pk, but what was that atrocious rebound? I understand the obsession over Channing Tatum, but is it that bad to where you feel obligated to give him and Amanda a second chance at a goal? I have to agree with my colleague Bill: the goalkeeper’s form back to the other side was worse than the rebound. Grade: B

 

Kicking and Screaming

Bill: You remember the goalkeeper in youth soccer who just sat on their line for the entire game, never diving for anything, and let a defender take the goal kicks? That goalkeeper would be better than this one. There’s no plan here. He just barrels out hoping his reckless approach just happens to work out. Pass. I'd rather have traffic cone kid. Grade: F

Tim: I wish my AYSO games were as lit as this one was after the game-winning goal went in. That looked a lot like the 2017 USL Championship postgame. For the goalkeeping, there’s not much to be said. I think I would take Plank from Ed, Edd, and Eddy over this guy. How did they manage to make it to the final with this jabroni in between the pipes? Grade: F

Sarah: I do not know why they did not call 911 after that goal because Sam’s move around the goalkeeper absolutely broke his ankles. The goalkeeper couldn’t hold his ground. It looked as though he maybe needed to run to the bathroom. He also could not have attacked the forward/ball in a worse way. I think it’s time for this goalkeeper to hang up the cleats and find a different sport. Grade: D

 

Victory

Penalty save, starting at 10:00

Tim: The hand strength of Sylvester Stallone is extremely impressive, not to mention his ability to follow the ball into hands and eventually tuck and roll. Another fine example of the Allied powers showing the world why Fascism sucks. Grade: A+

Sarah: I always find it interesting to watch older soccer. It's amazing to see how the goalkeepers' abilities and skills evolve as the sport grows. In this goalkeeper-era, we see that their arms are baskets and they must catch that way. We also see the bold “no gloves” tactic. Risky, if you ask me. The key moment is at the end: the stare down. No words need to be said, just the glare from one player to another is enough to say “my balls are bigger than yours. I will save this shot”. Grade: A

Bill: Before going on to beat the best the Red Army had to offer, Rocky Balboa started his sporting career off strong by defeating the Axis alongside Pelé and Bobby Moore. Decades later we have endless hoopla over the advancement of goalkeeping equipment but at the end of the day, you can’t say any goalkeeping gloves have ever aided in the defeat of the Nazis. No, it was superior hand strength, pristine form, and insurmountable self-belief that propelled the Allies to win this war. Grade: A+

 

Scouting Report: Five U20 Goalkeepers Worth Remembering

cover photo belongs to Getty Images

Eric Lopez - Los Angeles Galaxy 2, 18

Lopez has quietly risen to prominence out west. While a number of his peers are in Europe, Lopez shows us that the US can still develop their own goalkeepers. Lopez, who turns 19 in March, has a good frame and moves well in the box. He's shown positive strides in his 1v1 approach and continues to fight for time in a highly competitive environment with LAG2. If Lopez continues to round out his game, he'll be fighting for playing time against Zack Steffen and Ethan Horvath soon enough.

 

Carlos dos Santos - Benfica, 17

CJ dos Santos (SLBenfica & USA) highlights~ for pictures and videos from 2012-present use HASHTAG dosGK on instagram, Facebook, and twitter.

With the way dos Santos covers the goal frame, it's hard not to think of David de Gea. Dos Santos possesses a massive spring to propel himself like no other USYNT prospect. But unlike de Gea, dos Santos plays with such an aggressive mindset that he'll insert himself into almost any play that enters the box. It's a tough playstyle to master, one we haven't witnessed in the American scene since Kevin Hartman, but if dos Santos can find that perfect balance, he'll be a strong presence down the line.

 

Laurel Ivory - University of Virginia, 18

Last fall Ivory was with the University of Virginia and this spring she's with the U20s in their current World Cup Qualifying campaign. Ivory is akin to recently acquired Utah Royals goalkeeper, EJ Proctor (or Ethan Horvath for Ivory's male counterpart). Ivory stays close to her line, relying on her ability to read the game and react from the goal mouth. She doesn't get overwhelmed in unfamiliar scenarios and isn't afraid to challenge crosses in the box. While she's a little undersized for an ideal goalkeeper, she more than makes up for it with her balance, game knowledge, and self-confidence.

 

Nicolas Defreitas-Hansen - Everton, 16

Watch 16 year old Nicolas Defreitas-Hansen saves and distribution for USA and Everton academy team in the U18 Premier League.

When a sixteen-year-old is starting for a Premier League U18 team, it's a safe bet to say he's a pretty decent player. Defreitas-Hansen sits right around 6'0" and has a deceptively quick post-to-post time. Similar to Ivory, Defreitas-Hansen prefers to stand players up but does a great job of keeping his weight forward and his feet under him. Reportedly Defreitas-Hansen can also play for Brazil and Denmark but he's only represented the US thus far, making three appearances with the U16s.

 

Hillary Beall - University of Michigan, 19

With most tall goalkeepers, they struggle to move from side-to-side and to quickly drop to the ground. Fortunately for the University of Michigan, Beall has shown the agility to take her game past college. The 5'11" goalkeeper can move in the box and has strong hands to complement her play. Beall made seven starts her freshmen year and is poised to take over as the starter for the Wolverines in 2018.

2018 Draft Review - Winners and Losers

cover photo belongs to Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

Between the NWSL and MLS drafts from last week, a total of twelve goalkeepers were selected over 132 picks. Some teams came away from the weekend with significant gains in their goalkeeping core while some did little to help themselves. Here are three winners and losers from the draft weekend.

 

Winners

Houston Dynamo - By the time their 21st pick rolled around, Eric Dick (SKC) and Jeff Caldwell (NYC) were already taken off the board so perhaps Houston would have gone a different direction had they selected first. Regardless, they ended up with three goalkeepers by the end of the weekend, as two goalkeepers were signed to Houston's USL affiliate. Houston was able to fill out their goalkeeping core so quickly in large part to their first ever goalkeeper combine. The Dynamo were thorough in their research, worked with a variety of possible options, and brought in three known goalkeepers without any hanging questions over what they were getting.

Utah Royals FC - No one knows when the ageless wonder Nicole Barnhart will retire. The 36-year-old has played in all but 7 games in the NWSL's entire history and there aren't many signs of her slowing down. Assuming Barnhart will retire at some point, Utah now has a goalkeeper to turn the reins over to. The Royals were able to snag EJ Proctor despite only having two picks to their name. The Duke alum fell into Utah's lap late in the draft and they weren't sleeping when their pick came up. With a couple years of training under Barnhart, Proctor has the ability to grow into a trusted starter, if not a top name in the NWSL.

Minnesota United - Most backups in the league don't arrive with $175,000 in allocated money but Minnesota picked up Matt Lampson from Chicago with the added bonus. Lampson also comes in at a lighter price than last year's goalkeeper, John Albvage ($247,000). Lampson will probably sign for around $120,000, saving Minnesota a net $300,000 from last year's group of goalkeepers. For only having to move down twelve spots in the first round, Minnesota walked away with deeper pockets and a much stronger goalkeeping situation.

 

Losers

Seattle Sounders - To be fair, no one was expecting that many goalkeepers to be selected so quickly and Seattle were quickly left out in the cold. An unprecedented four goalkeepers were selected in the first round, right before the Sounders' pick. The Sounders only have two goalkeepers between their MLS and USL squads and still need three more. Seattle didn't pick up a goalkeeper with any of their three picks and their fourth-round pick they traded to DC went completely unused, as United simply passed on the draft's penultimate pick. Acknowledging some misfortune on Seattle's part, the Sounders still didn't utilize the weekend to help out their goalkeeping rosters.

Portland Thorns - The Thorns already have two reliable goalkeepers: Adrianna Franch (2017 NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year) and backup Britt Eckerstrom, who is currently playing in Australia over the winter break. The Thorns traded their 2019 third round pick on draft day to move up for Bella Geist. It'd be an understandable move if they hadn't sent two fourth-round picks for Eckerstrom less than a year ago. With only have two roster spots for goalkeepers, it's a waste of draft picks and ultimately one talented goalkeeper. One of the three goalkeepers isn't signing on for 2018 and the resources they used to obtain that goalkeeper will end up going to waste as well.

Colorado Rapids - The Rapids have a long tradition of mishandling young goalkeepers. If Zac MacMath's situation wasn't clear enough, the Rapids have drafted goalkeeper after goalkeeper, only to see them retire or land on another team's roster soon after. Over the twelve, now thirteen, goalkeepers the Rapids have drafted in their history, they've only seen a combined 53 appearances from the draftees. It's a long list of failed projects and Thomas Olsen doesn't seem set to change the course. Never a first-team goalkeeper in the West Coast Conference, (most recently losing out to Paul Christensen, who was still available in the third round) the U20 World Cup alum still needs help developing his aerial game (I'm a little skeptical of his listed 6'3" height) and not diving backwards when things get tight. There's a big project on Colorado's hands but if the Rapids are true to nature, they won't spend much time helping Olsen craft his game.

2018 MLS Mock Draft - Goalkeeper Edition

The 2018 MLS SuperDraft is less than three weeks away and this year's senior class has a number of goalkeepers who look more than ready for the next level. It's the strongest goalkeeping class since 2007, which featured Luis Robles, Tally Hall, Chris Seitz, Chris Konopka, and Kyle Reynish.

Dating back to the 2013 SuperDraft, 28 goalkeepers have been selected over a combined 330 picks. (Not counting Evan Louro's homegrown signing with the Red Bulls.) Although there are exceptions, teams typically don't draft goalkeepers until the top field players have been selected. Four goalkeepers over the past four years went in the first round, while the other 24 went in the second, third, or fourth round. However the late start on goalkeepers makes them a higher commodity in later rounds, where it's not rare to see a wave of goalkeeper picks once one is selected. 

Knowing that anything can happen on draft day, there are some safer bets than others. Chicago, FC Dallas, Montreal, NYC and Sporting Kansas City are all filled at the goalkeeping position while Houston, Orlando, and Seattle are all in the greatest need. No collegiate goalkeeper will be vying for starting minutes right away. Instead MLS teams will be looking more long term, filling their USL rosters or a number three slot. There are 92 picks this year, which puts MLS teams on "pace" to select 7.8 goalkeepers over the four rounds. Let's find eight goalkeepers homes in MLS.

 

1. Jeff Caldwell - Houston Dynamo, 1st Round

photo from The Sounder Fan

photo from The Sounder Fan

There's a decent chance Caldwell falls to the Dynamo late in the first round. MLS teams are historically skittish in selecting a goalkeeper early into the draft unless they're confident in handing out a guaranteed MLS contract, which Caldwell will most definitely want. There are other teams in need of goalkeepers ahead of Houston but the field player-heavy draft could see those teams waiting until the second round to pickup a goalkeeper. Houston only have one goalkeeper signed between their MLS and USL squads and Caldwell is someone who could be playing in MLS in 2-3 years. There's a big enough need that the Dynamo could theoretically end up with two goalkeepers this draft but at the very least Houston should snag one of the top goalkeepers.

 

2. Eric Dick - Seattle Sounders, 1st Round

There's always the chance Seattle signs Paul Christensen as a homegrown option but something tells me if it hasn't happened by now, it's not going to happen. Seattle is known for having a good core of goalkeepers with their USL side and Eric Dick will certainly bolster the currently empty roster. At the end of the first round, the Sounders will have to wonder if there are really that many better options elsewhere and what goalkeepers will be left by the end of the second round.

 

3. Ben Lundgaard - Colorado Rapids, 2nd Round

Virginia Tech Athletics

Virginia Tech Athletics

Colorado are currently sitting on five draft picks so it's likely they'll use one on a goalkeeper at some point. Lundgaard won ACC Goalkeeper of the Year over Caldwell and has the type of save in his repertoire to keep his team in games they probably shouldn't be in. The only problem is that the Rapids' haven't had much success in drafting goalkeepers in the past, mostly due to their own fault. The last goalkeeper they drafted, Ohio State alum Chris Froschauer, they prompted dropped the following summer after they brought Tim Howard in. The Rapids should leave the draft with a promising prospect but after six failed attempts at drafting an eventual starting goalkeeper, Rapids fans may not want to be holding their breath on this one.

 

4. Michael Nelson - DC United, 2nd Round

SMU Athletics

SMU Athletics

There's going to be a point in the draft when goalkeepers are flying off the board and teams are going to look at Nelson as a safe pick, as they should. He has the frame and composure to succeed at the next level, as shown with a successful tournament run with SMU. DC have had as many as four goalkeepers on an MLS contract in the past and if they truly are considering a USL side for 2019, Nelson is a good place to start.

 

5. Paul Christensen - Atlanta United, 2nd Round

photo from The Sounder Fan

photo from The Sounder Fan

If Atlanta are still aiming for starting a USL affiliate in 2018, they'll need at least two more goalkeepers. We haven't heard any more news about the expansion since November, so I wouldn't be completely surprised if the plan was put on pause for another year but pessimism aside, Christensen would be a fine fit in Atlanta. He's a tad undersized for a traditional MLS goalkeeper but he makes up for it in quickness and reactions. The USYNT product has the option of signing with Seattle as a homegrown but with so much time passing, it's likely that Seattle hasn't offered it or Christensen wants to try his luck elsewhere. I would expect Christensen to want an MLS contract, similar to Jack McGuire last year, and Atlanta seems like the type of team that would be willing to oblige.

 

6. Drew Shepherd - Philadelphia Union, 3rd Round

WMU Athletics

WMU Athletics

MLS drafts have been kind to goalkeepers from small schools and Shepherd was a part of possibly the most successful class in Western Michigan University's history. Philadelphia already have a young goalkeeping core with three goalkeepers under 28 but none rostered with Bethlehem Steel. The Union have three draft picks in the last two rounds and goalkeepers are traditionally safer picks than field players. Shepherd doesn't have a ton of press going into the draft so to see him go undrafted wouldn't be a shock, although he's shown the ability and determination to get to the next level one way or another.

 

7. Scott Levene - New York Red Bulls, 4th Round

Steve Slade

Steve Slade

Similar to Philadelphia, the Red Bulls need USL goalkeepers. However the Red Bulls are in an interesting position with no third round selections and with Robles on the backend of his career, they could afford to be a little more aggressive with their second round pick. Levene has 70 collegiate games to his name - much more compared to his peers  - from the same university that produced Andre Blake. So for whichever team Levene ends up at, they'll be receiving a much-tested goalkeeper.

 

8. Nico Corti - Los Angeles FC, 4th Round

Stanford Athletics

Stanford Athletics

In contrast to Levene, Corti doesn't have a ton of game experience under his belt, less than 2200 minutes played in his collegiate career. Fortunately for Corti, he earned a national championship for his résumé and never looked uncomfortable when in goal. While I'm aware Orlando doesn't have a 4th round pick, it's not that tricky to obtain a late round draft pick. OCSC need another three goalkeepers to fill out their MLS/USL rosters and starting in the draft is as good of time as any. It's a low-risk/high-reward situation for OCSC to make a play for the senior Cardinal.

Update: Orlando City has quietly announced that their USL squad will not compete in 2018 so Corti slides to LAFC. Stanford is a cool five hours north of LA and you'd hope the new MLS team would be aware of a national champion in their backyard. LA still needs a starter but they also don't have a third string goalkeeper yet. Corti would be a fine addition for them.