College soccer has long been a home to the country’s top goalkeepers. Although some schools have come and gone, to be named the best goalkeeper in the country at the collegiate level will always be a prestigious award, no matter what year it was given. Below is a record of the top collegiate goalkeepers since 1905, as compiled to the best of our ability.
Accurate information on the history of the college game isn’t always readily available, if not been lost outright over the decades, so some gaps have been filled in to best represent each era. Most notably, men’s teams listed as runner-ups before 1959 were selected by Everybody Soccer, as well as men’s teams listed as the top four seeded before 1989. Additionally, there were no national champions selected from 1941-1945, so a top four (and national champion) was also selected by Everybody Soccer.
On the women’s side, teams listed as the top four seeded before 1986 were selected by Everybody Soccer to showcase the top teams entering the tournament, as there isn't any verification of seeds given during this time. Lastly, as Everybody Soccer has been highlighting the country’s top goalkeepers for over a decade, Everybody Soccer’s own top goalkeepers is listed as well, following as a spiritual successor to the ISAA Goalkeeper of the Year award, which ran from the mid-1980s until 1995.
Notice any errors? Please reach out through the contact page.
Tips for using the table: Scroll right for more information. Click a heading, year, or decade to collapse that row or column. Click on goalkeepers or schools to see isolated information.