MLS Academy Success Rate

The current top youth league in the country is called MLS NEXT and features many of our top prospects competing in MLS academies across multiple age groups. But this league didn’t come together overnight. We have to wind back to 2007 to understand how MLS NEXT came to be.

In 1996, Major League Soccer became the home for American soccer players to continue to develop as top professionals in our country. In 2007, the US Soccer Federation wanted to expand its commitment to the American player by creating a top youth league for all American players. With MLS still struggling to make ends meet, the federation launched the Development Academy (DA), a non-profit premier league to help bridge aspiring young soccer players into a pre-professional route. The following year, MLS introduced the Homegrown Player rule, which allowed MLS teams to sign players from their own academies, rewarding MLS teams for their efforts in player development in the DA. Both the federation and MLS were creating avenues to help streamline our country’s best players’ pathway to the top.

How We Got Here

The DA was originally reluctant to expand much past its original 64 teams for the first decade, but the league eventually ballooned to hundreds of teams in hopes of bringing more players under the federation’s scouting structures. But costs started mounting as the league expanded. By the time COVID cut off the cash flow that helped run the DA, the league had swelled to about $12 million in annual operating costs. And with no national team games bringing in ticket sales and sponsorship income, the federation had other bills to worry about. For about a year, the federation had been in court with the USWNT, arguing that the men’s national team had "a higher level of skill based on speed and strength" and carried "more responsibility” than the women’s national team, an argument that cost it its president, several corporate sponsors, and eventually a $24 million backpay settlement, on the way to a roughly $50 million financial hit across the board. (The Federation’s law firm was immediately fired after making this argument in court.)

The financial strain wasn’t the only concern surrounding the league. A once-buzzing league, the DA had fallen to the point where clubs were opting for a rival league, the ECNL, citing more flexibility, no restriction on playing high school soccer, and lower operating costs. The federation, frustrated at the league’s situation and needing to find ways to cut costs internally, turned to MLS to offload the country’s premier youth league.

As the federation closed the DA’s doors, so went the federation’s responsibility to foot the bill. Although parents and clubs were paying the bulk up front, that still left a lot of expenses on the federation to run the league. But with MLS taking the reins, the federation could now cut expenses like scouting hundreds of non-MLS clubs, running intensive nationwide events, training DA coaches to get the appropriate badge to coach in the DA at a discount, as well as letting go of 40-50 staff centered around the DA. The restructuring helped the federation reclaim its financial footing, amassing to $250 million in annual revenue with $80 million in reserves.

Rising From the Ashes

In creating a setup to get the best bang for their buck, US Soccer’s lack of international training compensation standards was a thorn in MLS’s side. Once originally viewed as a positive to allow MLS teams to cherry-pick the best players in the country, now MLS’ highly rated prospects were walking to Europe for free. In 2019, the highly publicized DeAndre Yedlin lawsuit resulted in FIFA formally declaring that American youth clubs are fully entitled to solidarity payments and training compensation, which was a double-edged sword for MLS. Either MLS could have US Soccer co-sign on MLS reaping all the solidarity payments from other countries or US Soccer could protect MLS teams to ensure their academy products don’t walk away for free. But they couldn’t do both. It was solidarity payments for all parties with international movement or none at all.

However, in 2024, MLS established the MLS NEXT Development Grant program to help maximize resources pointing back to MLS. Under the grant program, if an MLS team signs an independent MLS NEXT club’s player to a first team contract, the MLS team pays that independent club an upfront development grant of up to $30,000, while also guaranteeing any future sell-on percentages. Although this wouldn’t apply for academy-to-academy movement (without a first team contract), MLS offset any future expenses with a $5,000 annual fee for each team in MLS NEXT. For the 120 independent clubs with multiple age groups paying around a total of $25,000 a year, MLS NEXT quickly offset any administrative overhead as no MLS academy has to pay these fees. These efforts helped protect and bolster MLS’s resources and - combined with U.S. Soccer's reluctance to scout outside the league - forced many independent clubs to join MLS NEXT so they could potentially stop the bleeding of their top talents walking into an MLS academy without gaining anything in return.

Lastly, the DA-to-MLS NEXT transition was also focused on moving away from a widespread attempt to scout the entire country’s best players and, instead, maximizing MLS’s resources and investments. Although there was good competition in the DA's final years - Strikers FC and Sockers FC had reached the U18/U19 semifinals, and Texans SC had won the 2017 U17/18 national title - MLS NEXT placed MLS academies into their own conferences so they could focus on developing professional players without interference from independent clubs. With the structure and protection for MLS teams pulling the independent clubs’ best players, the cream would rise to the top one way and be left to MLS to finish the development process.

Tracking MLS NEXT’s Successes

For this project, every MLS team (and selected non-MLS teams) had their U16 and older goalkeepers tracked to see how they developed after leaving the academy. The chart below lists every keeper who came through an MLS NEXT academy, starting at U16, and objectively rates how their careers turned out. With MLS NEXT giving MLS academies the top conferences, first claim on players, and control of the money, we’re left with the question, “How successful are MLS academies at producing more players who go on to play at the next level?"

Since no single place had all this information, AI was used to scrape together what was available across the internet. Of course, if any information is wrong or incomplete, please use the contact page, and an update will be made ASAP.

NCAA Men's Goalkeeper Rankings (Preseason Fall 2026)

Goalkeepers are ranked based on a number of factors, mostly boiling down to recent performances and long-term potential. Everybody Soccer does its best to cover the hundreds of goalkeepers in collegiate soccer but ultimately it’s a team effort to platform the deserving goalkeepers. So if someone wishes to put a goalkeeper on the radar - or if you simply have questions or comments about the article - please reach out via the contact page.

Seniors

1. Nigel Van Haveren (FIU, Netherlands)
2. Wyatt Nelson (UCLA)
3. Rowan Schnebly (Stanford)
4. Seth Wilson (UNC Greensboro)
5. Devin Armstrong (Seton Hall)
6. Scott Williams (UC Irvine)
7. Andrew Samuels (Princeton)
8. Justin Stewart (Oregon State)
9. Marius Helias (Rider, France)
10. Owen Cornell (UIC)

11. Zack Andoh (California)
12. Jadon Bowton (Washington)
13. Kael McGowan (Southern Indiana)
14. Jonathan Munteanu (USC Upstate)
15. Levi Bieber (Seattle)
16. Eddie DeMarco (Louisville)
17. Cal L’Hommedieu (Washington U, D3)
18. Trevor Maloney (VCU)
19. Ky Mani Dade (Loyola Marymount)
20. Alex Svetanoff (Charlotte)

Storylines to Watch: Just so everyone is on the same page: there are no serious 25 year old goalkeepers in the college ranks. Without going roster-by-roster, there’s likely around a single-digit number of goalkeepers at that age in all of Division 1 soccer. However, they’re not playing college soccer at that age because they’re an amazing talent. The only reason a 25 year old goalkeeper is still playing college soccer is that it’s the only level that will take them, not to mention they’re a year or so away from retirement. College is the end of the line for these goalkeepers because they’re barely at the level, not way above it.

That said, it doesn’t mean there aren’t goalkeepers who took a winding path to get here. Armstrong, Williams, Stewart, Munteanu, and Svetanoff hit the transfer portal in hopes of finding a good springboard to wrap up their collegiate careers with.

Expect to see Schnebly, Wilson, Samuels, Andoh, and, of course, reigning national champion Bowton in postseason play. There aren’t many “easy” games in Division I, so even though they’ll be on one of the better squads more times than not, their teams will still need to see big saves throughout the season, not just in November.

Although there are some smaller schools to keep tabs on - McGowan and L’Hommedieu doing their best to put their universities on the map - watch out for Van Haveren and Wyatt to set the tone for the season. Both have an immensely high ceiling but 2025 was a tumultuous season for both goalkeepers. If they can get back to the good run they had before, they’ll be All-American candidates. If not, they’ll end up being some of the biggest “what ifs” in collegiate goalkeeping since the turn of the century.

Juniors

1. Blake Kelly (Notre Dame)
2. Matisse Hebert (UCF, Canada)
3. Jonah Mednard (Wake Forest)
4. Kyle Durham (Connecticut)
5. Matthew Hudson (Creighton)
6. Charles DeMarco (Georgetown)
7. Alastair Hafner Schnee (Holy Cross)
8. Sebastian Stanaj (Oakland)
9. Philip Hovers (Loyola Marymount)
10. Declan Finnegan (IU Indianapolis)

11. Kyle Jansen (Syracuse)
12. Leo Ledin (Virginia Tech, Sweden)
13. Aleksandar Kolar (Cleveland State)
14. Marten Brink (College of Charleston, Germany)
15. Connor O'Keefe (Loyola Maryland)
16. Carlito Saylon (Tulsa)
17. Kai Darrell (Williams, D3)

Storylines to Watch: Not a whole lot to build off of with this group. Although there are some standouts, the class is largely filled with goalkeepers off the radar at either smaller schools or ones who haven’t quite got the play time to really make the waves they’re looking for. Jansen entered college with a lot of buzz but still hasn’t really capitalized on it yet, while goalkeepers like Ledin and Kolar showed impressive moments over the past couple of years but both are so far off scouts’ radars it’s hard to really tout them.

Kelly, Mednard, and Durham are the clear American standouts with pro potential but scouts are going to want to see them all be more than just pure shot stoppers, with the most egregious example being Mednard’s amazing triple save yet his reluctance to handle aerial service in Wake’s 5-4 loss to SMU to end their season. It’s one thing to be a top college goalkeeper, it’s another thing to be a top goalkeeper in even just the USL.

It’s a polarizing group, none of whom have really stood up and said “I’ll take it from here.” Hopefully in 2026, we get some real contenders for potential USMNT prospects. Otherwise it’ll just end up being another proto-MLS Next Pro group that gets lost in the wash in a few years.

Sophomores

1. Jonathan Evans (SMU)
2. Judewellin Michel (Wisconsin, Canada)
3. Luke Shrivers (Wisconsin)
4. Aleksander Kapciak (Seattle)
5. Nick Bishop (Portland)
6. Cole Kowalski (Notre Dame)
7. Alex Provost (Denison, D3)
8. Jacob English (Southern Indiana)
9. Payton Roehrich (Fort Hays St., D2)
10. Keegan O'Brien (Cal St. Dom. Hills, D2)

11. Owen Barnett (Wake Forest)
12. Nash Skoglund (Coastal Carolina)
13. Joseph Grossman (Connecticut)
14. Owen Beninga (UC Santa Barbara)
15. Keller Krieger (Grove City College, D3)
16. John W. Smith Jr. (Holy Cross)
17. Jayden Quemada (Northeast CC, JUCO)

Storylines to Watch: Where the juniors have dropped the ball in establishing themselves, the sophomores have picked up the slack, albeit from all over the country. Lower division goalkeepers showed well for themselves last fall from D2 to D3 to JUCO. Admittedly, the lower levels don’t have a great history of continuing development for goalkeepers, so don’t be surprised if any of these goalkeepers transfer to the D1 game for more exposure. But as for right now, they’ve shown well.

Obviously the goalkeeping battle at Wisconsin will be one to watch as the Badgers brought in Canadian Judewellin Michel to challenge returner Luke Shrivers for the number one spot. Usually head coaches don’t just casually bring in an international goalkeeper so maybe the competition is already decided, but keep an eye out regardless.

Other goalkeeping battles to watch include Seattle (Bieber-Kapciak), Notre Dame (Kelly-Kowalski), Wake Forest (Mednard-Barnett-Syrett), Connecticut (Durham-Grossman), and Holy Cross (Schnee-Smith). Although some of those schools have fairly established starters, expect to see the underclassmen find minutes here and there to make a case for themselves, if not outright take the starting position like Florida State’s women’s team did last fall.

Skoglund leaves South Carolina for Coastal and English was awkwardly announced as a transfer to Kentucky, despite being back at Southern Indiana (or never left?). However, it’s Evans’ move to SMU that stands out the most. The former Penn State freshman took the starting spot and ran with it last fall, conceding just 18 goals in 14 games for the Nittany Lions. But a move to SMU propels the Mustangs into an even more favorable position for a postseason run.

Freshmen

1. Quinn Syrett (Wake Forest)
2. Lucas McPartlin (Saint Louis)
3. James Romero (Oregon State)
4. Zach Cielewich (Maryland)
5. Kai Zeruhn (Columbia)
6. Felix Huebner (Loyola Maryland)
7. James Rhodes (Pittsburgh)
8. Jan Hejna (Harvard)
9. Cooper Roney (Loyola Marymount)
10. Nathan Juillard (Santa Clara)

Storylines to Watch: Although the same sentiment from the women’s ranking applies (TLDR: preseason rankings for first years are a crapshoot), the men’s game has an added wrinkle that the women’s game doesn’t have. Goalkeepers like McPartlin and Cielewich have foreign talent ahead of them on the depth chart. Although some fans love to tout overtly nationalistic complaints of foreigners taking Americans’ spots, our top goalkeepers actually are propelled forward with the foreign infusion. They aren’t simply handed a starting spot for four years. They must earn it. And although the bottom 99% admittedly lose playing time at these schools to the international players, there are 1500 colleges that would still love to have them, not to mention the hundreds of USCCS teams around the country as well.

Sure, it’d be nice if Americans were filling every spot and playing at a high level, but if the international players were removed, the overall level plummets and our top prospects are worse off. And ultimately, if our top prospects can’t compete with Europe’s washouts, then they’re not top prospects to begin with.

For those complaining about Americans not getting enough chances, raise your complaints to the professional level, not the college ranks. Our top collegiate prospects are lifted up by the international players, not dragged down.

Past Collegiate Goalkeeper Rankings

2025: Preseason and Final
2024: Preseason and Final
2023: Preseason and Final
2022: Preseason and Final
2021: Preseason and Final
2020: Preseason and Final
2019: Preseason and Final
2018: Preseason and Final
2017: Preseason and Final
2016: Preseason and Final
2015: Preseason and Final
2014: Preseason and Final

Gloves Off Interviews

Starting in 2024, Gloves Off features interviews with retired goalkeepers in American soccer. Highlighting the forgotten moments, standards of the times, and highs/lows with the goalkeeper’s career, Gloves Off aims to be a historical documentation of top goalkeepers from eras that came and went before the advent of social media. As the modern game continues to evolve the position of goalkeeping, Gloves Off looks to capture the stories of the pioneers in American soccer.

Gloves Off Interviews

Which School is Goalkeeper U?

At the end of 2025, Inside the 18 had a two-part discussion on deciding “Which School is ‘Goalkeeper U’?” The discussion was centered around a bracket of 64 schools facing off in the roundtable’s opinion of which school had the best history of showcasing and producing top goalkeepers. Each school was whittled down to their top seven goalkeepers and the roundtable of goalkeeper coaches picked the winner in each pairing.

Which School is Goalkeeper U? - Part 1
Which School is Goalkeeper U? - Part 2



The World's Best Goalkeepers

Everybody Soccer returns with its installment of the top goalkeepers in the world. Goalkeepers are rated on their form with club and country, taking into account their success in shot-stopping, distribution, cross-management, and ability to improv on a broken play. To view past rankings, you can click here to see the prior lists in a spreadsheet or visit the list of the top 24 goalkeepers under 24 years old. Cover photo from Srdjan Stevanovic and Getty Images.

The rankings were last updated July 1st, 2025.

1. Alisson

Alisson Becker, Liverpool’s Brazilian wall, has redefined goalkeeping in the Premier League since joining from AS Roma in 2018 for a then-record £66.8 million. His knack for jaw-dropping saves and pinpoint distribution helped Liverpool win the 2019 Champions League and 2020 Premier League, ending a 30-year title drought. A soccer tidbit: he scored a dramatic header against West Brom in 2021, becoming the first goalkeeper to net a competitive goal for Liverpool. In 2024-25, his 12 clean sheets kept Liverpool atop the league. At 33, he’s still Brazil’s No. 1, pushing for another World Cup run in 2026.

2. Thibaut Courtois

Thibaut Courtois, Real Madrid’s towering Belgian, has been a defensive cornerstone since arriving from Chelsea in 2018, helping secure three La Liga titles and two Champions Leagues by 2025. His 6’7” frame and cat-like reflexes shone in the 2022 Champions League final, where he made nine saves to stifle Liverpool. At the 2018 World Cup, he won the Golden Glove, proving his clutch factor on the global stage. Despite a 2023 ACL injury, he returned to form, posting 15 clean sheets in 2024-25. At 33, he’s still Real Madrid’s undisputed No. 1, eyeing more silverware.

3. Jan Oblak

Jan Oblak has been a brick wall since joining from Benfica in 2014, racking up five Zamora Trophies as La Liga’s best goalkeeper. His calm demeanor and uncanny shot-stopping led Atlético to the 2021 La Liga title and a 2024 Champions League semifinal run. Oblak holds the record for the fastest to 100 clean sheets in La Liga, hitting the mark in just 182 games. In 2024-25, his 14 clean sheets kept Atlético in the title race. At 32, he’s still the backbone of Diego Simeone’s gritty squad.

4. David de Gea

David de Gea, now with Fiorentina in Serie A after a storied 12-year stint at Manchester United, was once the Premier League’s gold standard, winning the Golden Glove in 2018 and 2023. His acrobatic saves, like the iconic 14-stop masterclass against Arsenal in 2017, defined his United legacy. He’s still the only goalkeeper to win Manchester United’s Player of the Year award three years running (2014-16). Since joining Fiorentina in 2024, he’s posted eight clean sheets in 2024-25, proving at 34 he’s still got it. He’s aiming to lead Spain at the 2026 World Cup.

5. David Raya

David Raya went from Brentford’s breakout star to the Gunners’ main man in net after a £27 million transfer in 2024. His fearless distribution and quick dives were crucial in Arsenal’s 2024 Premier League title push, where he notched 16 clean sheets. Raya is one of only two goalkeepers to keep a clean sheet in his first three Arsenal starts, matching a club record set in 1997. In 2024-25, his 13 shutouts have kept Arsenal in the hunt for the title. At 29 and a crowded depth chart, Raya has his work once again cut out for him to maintain his number one spot.

6. Gianluigi Donnarumma

Gianluigi Donnarumma has been a prodigy since debuting for AC Milan at 16 in 2015, and now, at 26, he’s already a Euro 2020 champion. His penalty shootout heroics against England in that final earned him the tournament’s Player of the Year. Donnarumma is the youngest goalkeeper to start a Champions League knockout match, doing so at 18 for Milan in 2017. With 11 clean sheets for PSG in 2024-25, he’s kept them atop Ligue 1. He’s now targeting a 2026 World Cup to cement his legacy as Italy’s greatest, as Italy is very close to the World Cup, according to World Cup Qualifiers odds at BetUS.

7. Emiliano Martinez

Emiliano Martínez went from Arsenal’s bench to World Cup glory in 2022, saving four penalties in shootouts to clinch the title for Argentina. His move to Villa in 2020 sparked a career revival, with his 15 clean sheets in 2022-23 earning him the Premier League Golden Glove. In back-to-back years (2022, 2023) Martínez won the Yashin Trophy. In 2024-25, his 10 clean sheets have Villa eyeing a Champions League spot. At 33, he’s Argentina’s undisputed No. 1, hungry for more trophies.

8. Alphonse Areola

Alphonse Areola has been a steady force since joining permanently from PSG in 2022, helping the Hammers win the 2023 Europa Conference League. His loan spells at Real Madrid and Fulham showcased his agility, but it’s at West Ham where he’s truly shone, with 12 clean sheets in 2024-25. Interestingly, he’s the only French goalkeeper to win a European trophy with an English club in the last decade. His dual Filipino-French heritage makes him a fan favorite globally. At 32, he’s pushing for a France recall ahead of the 2026 World Cup.

9. Iñaki Peña

Iñaki Peña, Barcelona’s homegrown goalkeeper, has been Marc-André ter Stegen’s deputy since breaking into the first team in 2018, stepping up in 2024-25 with 10 starts and five clean sheets during ter Stegen’s injury spells. A La Masia product, he won the 2023 La Liga title as a backup, but his recent performances show he’s ready for more. In 2023, Peña became one of only three goalkeepers to keep a clean sheet in El Clásico as a substitute. At 26, he’s patient but ambitious, eyeing Barcelona’s No. 1 spot and a Spain call-up.

10. Manuel Neuer

Manuel Neuer, Bayern Munich’s legendary German goalkeeper, revolutionized the position with his “sweeper-keeper” style, winning 11 Bundesliga titles and two Champions Leagues since joining in 2011. His heroics in Germany’s 2014 World Cup triumph earned him the Golden Glove. Neuer’s longevity led him to rack up such records as most clean sheets in the Bundesliga, surpassing 200 in 2023. Despite a 2023 leg injury, he returned to form with 14 clean sheets in 2024-25, keeping Bayern dominant. At 39, he’s still Germany’s top choice, aiming to bow out at the 2026 World Cup.

Best of the Rest
rank. name - club, nationality (age)

11. Kepa Arrizabalaga - Arsenal, Spain (30)
12. Unai Simón - Athletic Bilbao, Spain (28)
13. Ederson - Manchester City, Brazil (31)
14. Julen Agirrezabala - Athletic Bilbao, Spain (24)
15. Marc ter Stegen - Barcelona, Germany (33)
16. Keylor Navas - Newell's Old Boys, Costa Rica (38)
17. Arnau Tenas - PSG, Spain (24)
18. Alex Remiro - Real Sociedad, Spain (30)
19. Kasper Schmeichel - Celtic, Denmark (38)
20. Andriy Lunin - Real Madrid, Ukraine (26)

21. Kjell Scherpen - Brighton, Netherlands (25)
22. Dominik Kotarski - FC Copenhagen, Croatia (25)
23. Kevin Trapp - Eintracht Frankfurt, Germany (34)
24. Matvey Safonov - PSG, Russia (26)
25. Jordan Pickford - Everton, England (31)
26. Mike Maignan - AC Milan, France (30)
27. Edouard Mendy - Al-Ahli, Senegal (33)
28. Wojciech Szczesny - Barcelona, Poland (35)
29. Giorgi Mamardashvili - Liverpool, Georgia (24)
30. Yann Sommer - Inter Milan, Switzerland (36)

31. Fernando Muslera - Estudiantes, Uruguay (39)
32. Robert Sanchez - Chelsea, Spain (27)
33. Bernd Leno - Fulham, Germany (33)
34. Illan Meslier - Leeds United, France (25)
35. André Onana - Manchester United, Cameroon (29)
36. Philipp Köhn - Monaco, Switzerland (27)
37. Caoimhin Kelleher - Brentford, Ireland (26)
38. Aaron Ramsdale - Southampton, England (27)
39. Ortwin De Wolf - KV Mechelen, Belgium (29)
40. Dean Henderson - Crystal Palace, England (28)

41. Bartlomiej Dragowski - Panathinaikos, Poland (27)
42. Diego Conde - Villarreal, Spain (26)
43. Diogo Costa - Porto, Portugal (25)
44. Robin Zentner - Mainz, Germany (30)
45. Peter Gulacsi - RB Leipzig, Hungary (35)
46. Gerónimo Rulli - Marseille, Argentina (33)
47. Marwin Hitz - FC Basel, Switzerland (37)
48. Lucas Perri - Lyon, Brazil (27)
49. Paul Bernardoni - Yverdon Sport, France (28)
50. Colin Coosemans - Anderlecht, Belgium (32)