The current top youth league in the country is called MLS NEXT and features many of our top prospects competing in MLS academies across multiple age groups. But this league didn’t come together overnight. We have to wind back to 2007 to understand how MLS NEXT came to be.
In 1996, Major League Soccer became the home for American soccer players to continue to develop as top professionals in our country. In 2007, the US Soccer Federation wanted to expand its commitment to the American player by creating a top youth league for all American players. With MLS still struggling to make ends meet, the federation launched the Development Academy (DA), a non-profit premier league to help bridge aspiring young soccer players into a pre-professional route. The following year, MLS introduced the Homegrown Player rule, which allowed MLS teams to sign players from their own academies, rewarding MLS teams for their efforts in player development in the DA. Both the federation and MLS were creating avenues to help streamline our country’s best players’ pathway to the top.
How We Got Here
The DA was originally reluctant to expand much past its original 64 teams for the first decade, but the league eventually ballooned to hundreds of teams in hopes of bringing more players under the federation’s scouting structures. But costs started mounting as the league expanded. By the time COVID cut off the cash flow that helped run the DA, the league had swelled to about $12 million in annual operating costs. And with no national team games bringing in ticket sales and sponsorship income, the federation had other bills to worry about. For about a year, the federation had been in court with the USWNT, arguing that the men’s national team had "a higher level of skill based on speed and strength" and carried "more responsibility” than the women’s national team, an argument that cost it its president, several corporate sponsors, and eventually a $24 million backpay settlement, on the way to a roughly $50 million financial hit across the board. (The Federation’s law firm was immediately fired after making this argument in court.)
The financial strain wasn’t the only concern surrounding the league. A once-buzzing league, the DA had fallen to the point where clubs were opting for a rival league, the ECNL, citing more flexibility, no restriction on playing high school soccer, and lower operating costs. The federation, frustrated at the league’s situation and needing to find ways to cut costs internally, turned to MLS to offload the country’s premier youth league.
As the federation closed the DA’s doors, so went the federation’s responsibility to foot the bill. Although parents and clubs were paying the bulk up front, that still left a lot of expenses on the federation to run the league. But with MLS taking the reins, the federation could now cut expenses like scouting hundreds of non-MLS clubs, running intensive nationwide events, training DA coaches to get the appropriate badge to coach in the DA at a discount, as well as letting go of 40-50 staff centered around the DA. The restructuring helped the federation reclaim its financial footing, amassing to $250 million in annual revenue with $80 million in reserves.
Rising From the Ashes
In creating a setup to get the best bang for their buck, US Soccer’s lack of international training compensation standards was a thorn in MLS’s side. Once originally viewed as a positive to allow MLS teams to cherry-pick the best players in the country, now MLS’ highly rated prospects were walking to Europe for free. In 2019, the highly publicized DeAndre Yedlin lawsuit resulted in FIFA formally declaring that American youth clubs are fully entitled to solidarity payments and training compensation, which was a double-edged sword for MLS. Either MLS could have US Soccer co-sign on MLS reaping all the solidarity payments from other countries or US Soccer could protect MLS teams to ensure their academy products don’t walk away for free. But they couldn’t do both. It was solidarity payments for all parties with international movement or none at all.
However, in 2024, MLS established the MLS NEXT Development Grant program to help maximize resources pointing back to MLS. Under the grant program, if an MLS team signs an independent MLS NEXT club’s player to a first team contract, the MLS team pays that independent club an upfront development grant of up to $30,000, while also guaranteeing any future sell-on percentages. Although this wouldn’t apply for academy-to-academy movement (without a first team contract), MLS offset any future expenses with a $5,000 annual fee for each team in MLS NEXT. For the 120 independent clubs with multiple age groups paying around a total of $25,000 a year, MLS NEXT quickly offset any administrative overhead as no MLS academy has to pay these fees. These efforts helped protect and bolster MLS’s resources and - combined with U.S. Soccer's reluctance to scout outside the league - forced many independent clubs to join MLS NEXT so they could potentially stop the bleeding of their top talents walking into an MLS academy without gaining anything in return.
Lastly, the DA-to-MLS NEXT transition was also focused on moving away from a widespread attempt to scout the entire country’s best players and, instead, maximizing MLS’s resources and investments. Although there was good competition in the DA's final years - Strikers FC and Sockers FC had reached the U18/U19 semifinals, and Texans SC had won the 2017 U17/18 national title - MLS NEXT placed MLS academies into their own conferences so they could focus on developing professional players without interference from independent clubs. With the structure and protection for MLS teams pulling the independent clubs’ best players, the cream would rise to the top one way and be left to MLS to finish the development process.
Tracking MLS NEXT’s Successes
For this project, every MLS team (and selected non-MLS teams) had their U16 and older goalkeepers tracked to see how they developed after leaving the academy. The chart below lists every keeper who came through an MLS NEXT academy, starting at U16, and objectively rates how their careers turned out. With MLS NEXT giving MLS academies the top conferences, first claim on players, and control of the money, we’re left with the question, “How successful are MLS academies at producing more players who go on to play at the next level?"
Since no single place had all this information, AI was used to scrape together what was available across the internet. Of course, if any information is wrong or incomplete, please use the contact page, and an update will be made ASAP.