Seniors
1. Logan Erb (NC State)
2. Grant Calvert (Belmont)
3. Freddie Lapworth (Bucknell, England)
4. Alec McLachlan (St. John's, England)
5. Devin Armstrong (NJIT)
6. Nigel Van Haveren (FIU, Netherlands)
7. Marius Helias (Rider, France)
8. Scott Williams (New Hampshire)
9. Owen Cornell (UIC)
10. Joseph Andema (Clemson, Ghana)
11. James Lowell (Marist)
12. Jonathan Kliewer (Missouri State)
13. Zac Kelly (Michigan State)
14. Brian Lanier (Seattle Pacific, D2)
15. Jackson Leavitt (Elon)
16. Tim Baerwalde (Presbyterian, Germany)
17. Tomas Hut (Syracuse)
18. Mitchell Budler (Akron)
19. Sebastian Conlon (Kentucky)
20. Ciaran Dalton (Rutgers)
Storylines to Watch: The senior class has a bit of “island of misfit toys” vibe. Goalkeepers like Scott Williams, Owen Cornell, and Jonathan Kliewer showed qualities of a professional goalkeeper this fall but all have very limited career minutes to their names (none played in 2024). On the other side of the coin, we have goalkeepers carrying some professional prestige, like Logan Erb, Nigel Van Haveren, and Mitchell Budler, but their collegiate careers haven’t been the smoothest, whether needing to transfer or a lack of consistency on the field. Outside of the goalkeepers who played in the Final Four, which is an odd collection of schools in itself, it’s hard to say who is entering 2026 with momentum. That’s not to say there isn’t quality, but as to who will get a proper chance and investment, it's hard to say. Where some goalkeeper coaches see unfinished products, some see untapped potential.
Juniors
1. Rowan Schnebly (Stanford)
2. Aidan Crawford (Loyola-Chicago)
3. Seth Wilson (UNC Greensboro)
4. Wyatt Nelson (UCLA)
5. Jonathan Munteanu (Dayton)
6. Justin Stewart (Western Oregon, D2)
7. Andrew Samuels (Princeton)
8. Philip Hovers (Loyola Marymount)
9. Josh Caron (High Point)
10. Jakob Buhrkuhl (Memphis)
Storylines to Watch: The most obvious one is tracking Justin Stewart’s detour to Division 2. The FC Dallas product has the game-saving action in his toolkit but injuries have plagued his collegiate career thus far, featuring in only nine matches this fall. It’s not the odds on bet that he’ll make it to the pro game at this point, but with natural talent like his, you never count him out. Josh Caron is a strong representative for our short kings goalkeeping squads, leading High Point to a 14-2-4 record through scrappy and mobile play that allows him to cover more of the goal than one would expect. Schnebly, Crawford, Wilson, and Nelson all had strong moments this year, but none have really broken away from the pack. Similar to the seniors, it’s anyone’s game to say who will be the top prospect this time next year.
Sophomores
1. Blake Kelly (Notre Dame)
2. Matisse Hebert (Wisconsin, Canada)
3. Jonah Mednard (Wake Forest)
4. Charles DeMarco (Georgetown)
5. Levi Bieber (Washington)
6. Kyle Durham (Connecticut)
7. Alastair Hafner Schnee (Holy Cross)
8. Declan Finnegan (IU Indianapolis)
9. Tom Mabon (UAB, France)
10. Leo Ledin (Virginia Tech, Sweden)
11. Sebastian Stanaj (Oakland)
12. Weston Joyner (Chico State, D2)
Storylines to Watch: If you missed Mednard’s triple save or the sock advertising that came along with it, then you are really missing out on what is effectively the save of the season. Mednard and Kelly will battle for top Americans in the class for the next couple years, but don’t rule out goalkeepers coming out of left field, similar to Memphis’ junior goalkeeper Jakob Buhrkuhl, who transferred in from Lee University. With the portal becoming a more viable route to bolster your athletic career, expect to see even more movement between colleges going forward.
Freshmen
1. Jonathan Evans (Penn State)
2. Matthew Hudson (Creighton)
3. Lenno Schmidt (Rhode Island, Germany)
4. Emil Holmberg (East Tennessee State, Sweden)
5. Judewellin Michel (Indiana, Canada)
6. Luke Shrivers (Wisconsin)
7. Payton Roehrich (Fort Hays State, D2)
8. Alex Provost (Denison, D3)
9. Jacob English (Southern Indiana)
10. John W. Smith Jr. (Holy Cross)
11. Ryan Carney (Providence)
12. Keller Krieger (Grove City College, D3)
13. Keegan O'Brien (Cal St. Dom. Hills, D2)
Storylines to Watch: Obviously there were MLS alumni who showcased well this fall - Evans, Hudson, and Carney - but every year is a healthy reminder that there are always quality goalkeepers at schools you’ve never heard of and came out of clubs you’ve also never heard of. Now the question to what their development looks like moving forward is impossible to answer, but in the right environment they could blossom just like Champions League veteran and Division 2 product Josh Cohen. Keep an eye on universities to see if they can figure out if they want to continue to outsource the goalkeeping position to international talent or sharpen their recruiting efforts to bring in someone without a transatlantic flight.
Past Collegiate Goalkeeper Rankings
2025: Preseason
2024: Preseason and Final
2023: Preseason and Final
2022: Preseason and Final
2021: Preseason and Final
2020: Preseason and Final
2019: Preseason and Final
2018: Preseason and Final
2017: Preseason and Final
2016: Preseason and Final
2015: Preseason and Final
2014: Preseason and Final