NCAA Women's Goalkeeper Rankings (Fall 2025)

Bill Reno November 23, 2025

Seniors

1. Pauline Nelles (Arizona State, Germany)
2. Jordan Nytes (Colorado)
3. Keara Fitzgerald (Washington State) #
4. Jordan Brown (Georgia) #
5. Teagan Wy (California)
6. Olivia Pratapas (NC State)
7. Taylor Rath (Utah State)
8. Erin Jones (Old Dominion)
9. Annabel Austen (Penn)
10. Molly Pritchard (Ohio State)

11. Bella Hollenbach (Milwaukee)
12. JLo Varada (Campbell, Puerto Rico)
13. Mac Titus (UT Martin)
14. Katie Bahn (Sam Houston State)
15. Sophine Kevorkian (LSU)
16. Addy Holgorsen (Clemson)
17. Belle Okoroafo (West Florida, D2)
18. Ally Zazzara (Tennessee)
19. Hannah Dickinson (Villanova)
20. Kamryn Willoughby (Eastern Washington)
21. Bella Grust (USC)
22. Caroline Duffy (Oklahoma)
23. Faith Nguyen (Texas Tech)
24. Camryn Miller (Cincinnati)
25. Tallulah Miller (Monmouth) #

# - did not finish season due to injury

Storylines to Watch: Although the NWSL followed the USL Super League’s footsteps in removing their annual college draft, every professional side is still narrowing down their top options to pull in for next season. Injuries unfortunately derailed Fitzgerald, Brown, and Miller’s momentum. We’re sending good vibes for a smooth recovery to the talented prospects and hopefully seeing them back on the field soon. Goalkeepers like Nytes, Wy, and Jones have significant strengths but are far from being rounded out goalkeepers, often relying too heavily on their athleticism to be the answer to opposing teams’ attacks. Some outside options like Austen, Miller, and Hollenbach might be viewed with high value for some pro clubs but the level of consistency is something that’s going to need to be cleaned up if they want to continue playing at the next level. Similar to the men’s seniors, it’ll be interesting to see which goalkeepers are viewed as just good college goalkeepers versus which ones are rated as untapped potential.

Juniors

1. Izzy Lee (Illinois)
2. Aubrey Brown (SMU)
3. Olivia Shippee (Boston College)
4. Victoria Safradin (Virginia)
5. Kate Phillips (Missouri)
6. Jayden Emmanuel (Florida)
7. Olivia Bodmer (Rutgers)
8. Mallorie Benhart (South Dakota State)
9. Audur Scheving (LSU, Iceland)
10. Laurynn Ziller (UC Irvine)
11. Atlee Olofson (Miami)
12. Jackie Hollomon (Notre Dame)

Storylines to Watch: Izzy Lee is the main standout here, leading the Fighting Illini to their first 13 win season since 2011. A few of these goalkeepers - Brown, Emmanuel, Benhart - have some of the toolkit professional scouts are looking for, but despite all standing at 5’11” or 6’0”, they’ve been off most scouts’ radars for one reason or another. On the other side of the coin, goalkeepers like Olivia Shippee and Olivia Bodmer are highly mobile goalkeepers who don’t shy away from the chaos of the game. For each goalkeeper here who can round out their game a little more by solving problems through athleticism and a detailed blueprint to their game, expect a professional side to invest in them in 2027.

Sophomores

1. Liv Geller (TCU)
2. Sonoma Kasica (Notre Dame)
3. Caroline Dysart (Duke)
4. Keegan Smith (Arkansas)
5. Valentina Amaral (Wake Forest)
6. Sydney Fuller (Texas A&M)
7. Cameron Gabrielson (Georgetown)
8. Nona Reason (Clemson)
9. Sarah Wommack (Mississippi State)
10. Hannah Johann (North Carolina, Germany)

11. Sarah Martin (Minnesota)
12. Paloma Pena Toro (Florida, Dominican Republic)
13. Liya Brooks (North Carolina)
14. Mariangela Medina (UCLA, Mexico)
15. Jamie Campbell (Colorado)
16. Azul Alvarez (Baylor)
17. Genesis Perez Watson (UCF, Costa Rica)
18. Jillian Medvecky (Pepperdine)
19. Addie Todd (Florida State)
20. Nimu Karani (St. Louis)
21. Amaris Franco (Santa Clara)
22. Sammy Widnick (Drexel)

Storylines to Watch: Following the thread of inconsistency from the seniors and juniors, the entire sophomore class seems plagued by this issue. At times, you’ll drop your jaw looking at saves from Geller, Kasica, Wommock, or Johann and the next moment you’re seeing them give up a soft goal. Karani, Campbell, and Gabrielson faced extremely limited minutes this fall, but all showed signs of more to come in 2026. As far as natural talent goes, the sophomores are loaded but none have showcased a consistent level of play you’d expect to see from a future pro. This offseason will be a silent proving ground to see who’s willing to put the work in to elevate their game from “good” to “great”.

First Years

1. Kate Ockene (Florida State)
2. Khadijah Cisse (Kentucky, Canada)
3. Caroline Birkel (Stanford)
4. Noe Henning (Michigan State, Canada)
5. Charlotte Wilfert (UC San Diego)
6. Hannah Folliard (Georgia)
7. Evan O'Steen (Florida State)
8. Nyamma Nelson (Northwestern)
9. Daphne Nakfoor (UCLA)
10. Molly Vapensky (Duke)
11. Talisa Perez (UC Riverside)

Storylines to Watch: Ockene’s journey last fall went from being a quiet three-star recruit to winning the NCAA All-Tournament Defensive Most Outstanding Player award. Notching only 145 minutes through August and September, Ockene only gained momentum throughout the season, including a last-second save in the semifinal against TCU and an eight-save shutout in the final over Stanford. As to Evan O’Steen’s future with the school, it’s hard to say, but we’ve surely not seen the last of the starting goalkeeper for the United States’ U17s. Canada represented well this fall with Cisse and Henning, goalkeepers that US fans may come to remember well over the years, while some smaller schools like UC San Diego and UC Riverside received a strong return on investment with Wilfert and Perez. Although starting for a top school understandably comes with immense pressure, taking the number one spot as a first year when you’re expecting to see multiple chances on goal a game takes a specific amount of confidence as well.

Past Collegiate Goalkeeper Rankings

2025: Preseason
2024: Preseason and Final
2023: Preseason and Final
2022: Preseason and Final
2021: Preseason and Final
2020: Preseason and Final
2019: Preseason and Final
2018: Preseason and Final
2017: Preseason and Final
2016: Preseason and Final
2015: Preseason and Final

NCAA Men's Goalkeeper Rankings (Fall 2025)

Bill Reno November 23, 2025

Seniors

1. Logan Erb (NC State)
2. Grant Calvert (Belmont)
3. Freddie Lapworth (Bucknell, England)
4. Alec McLachlan (St. John's, England)
5. Devin Armstrong (NJIT)
6. Nigel Van Haveren (FIU, Netherlands)
7. Marius Helias (Rider, France)
8. Scott Williams (New Hampshire)
9. Owen Cornell (UIC)
10. Joseph Andema (Clemson, Ghana)

11. James Lowell (Marist)
12. Jonathan Kliewer (Missouri State)
13. Zac Kelly (Michigan State)
14. Brian Lanier (Seattle Pacific, D2)
15. Jackson Leavitt (Elon)
16. Tim Baerwalde (Presbyterian, Germany)
17. Tomas Hut (Syracuse)
18. Mitchell Budler (Akron)
19. Sebastian Conlon (Kentucky)
20. Ciaran Dalton (Rutgers)

Storylines to Watch: The senior class has a bit of “island of misfit toys” vibe. Goalkeepers like Scott Williams, Owen Cornell, and Jonathan Kliewer showed qualities of a professional goalkeeper this fall but all have very limited career minutes to their names (none played in 2024). On the other side of the coin, we have goalkeepers carrying some professional prestige, like Logan Erb, Nigel Van Haveren, and Mitchell Budler, but their collegiate careers haven’t been the smoothest, whether needing to transfer or a lack of consistency on the field. Outside of the goalkeepers who played in the Final Four, which is an odd collection of schools in itself, it’s hard to say who is entering 2026 with momentum. That’s not to say there isn’t quality, but as to who will get a proper chance and investment, it's hard to say. Where some goalkeeper coaches see unfinished products, some see untapped potential.

Juniors

1. Rowan Schnebly (Stanford)
2. Aidan Crawford (Loyola-Chicago)
3. Seth Wilson (UNC Greensboro)
4. Wyatt Nelson (UCLA)
5. Jonathan Munteanu (Dayton)
6. Justin Stewart (Western Oregon, D2)
7. Andrew Samuels (Princeton)
8. Philip Hovers (Loyola Marymount)
9. Josh Caron (High Point)
10. Jakob Buhrkuhl (Memphis)

Storylines to Watch: The most obvious one is tracking Justin Stewart’s detour to Division 2. The FC Dallas product has the game-saving action in his toolkit but injuries have plagued his collegiate career thus far, featuring in only nine matches this fall. It’s not the odds on bet that he’ll make it to the pro game at this point, but with natural talent like his, you never count him out. Josh Caron is a strong representative for our short kings goalkeeping squads, leading High Point to a 14-2-4 record through scrappy and mobile play that allows him to cover more of the goal than one would expect. Schnebly, Crawford, Wilson, and Nelson all had strong moments this year, but none have really broken away from the pack. Similar to the seniors, it’s anyone’s game to say who will be the top prospect this time next year.

Sophomores

1. Blake Kelly (Notre Dame)
2. Matisse Hebert (Wisconsin, Canada)
3. Jonah Mednard (Wake Forest)
4. Charles DeMarco (Georgetown)
5. Levi Bieber (Washington)
6. Kyle Durham (Connecticut)
7. Alastair Hafner Schnee (Holy Cross)
8. Declan Finnegan (IU Indianapolis)
9. Tom Mabon (UAB, France)
10. Leo Ledin (Virginia Tech, Sweden)
11. Sebastian Stanaj (Oakland)
12. Weston Joyner (Chico State, D2)

Storylines to Watch: If you missed Mednard’s triple save or the sock advertising that came along with it, then you are really missing out on what is effectively the save of the season. Mednard and Kelly will battle for top Americans in the class for the next couple years, but don’t rule out goalkeepers coming out of left field, similar to Memphis’ junior goalkeeper Jakob Buhrkuhl, who transferred in from Lee University. With the portal becoming a more viable route to bolster your athletic career, expect to see even more movement between colleges going forward.

Freshmen

1. Jonathan Evans (Penn State)
2. Matthew Hudson (Creighton)
3. Lenno Schmidt (Rhode Island, Germany)
4. Emil Holmberg (East Tennessee State, Sweden)
5. Judewellin Michel (Indiana, Canada)
6. Luke Shrivers (Wisconsin)
7. Payton Roehrich (Fort Hays State, D2)
8. Alex Provost (Denison, D3)
9. Jacob English (Southern Indiana)
10. John W. Smith Jr. (Holy Cross)
11. Ryan Carney (Providence)
12. Keller Krieger (Grove City College, D3)
13. Keegan O'Brien (Cal St. Dom. Hills, D2)

Storylines to Watch: Obviously there were MLS alumni who showcased well this fall - Evans, Hudson, and Carney - but every year is a healthy reminder that there are always quality goalkeepers at schools you’ve never heard of and came out of clubs you’ve also never heard of. Now the question to what their development looks like moving forward is impossible to answer, but in the right environment they could blossom just like Champions League veteran and Division 2 product Josh Cohen. Keep an eye on universities to see if they can figure out if they want to continue to outsource the goalkeeping position to international talent or sharpen their recruiting efforts to bring in someone without a transatlantic flight.

Past Collegiate Goalkeeper Rankings

NCAA Men's Goalkeeper Rankings (Preseason Fall 2025)

Bill Reno August 8, 2025

Seniors

1. Nigel Van Haveren (FIU, Netherlands)
2. Freddie Lapworth (Bucknell, England)
3. Logan Erb (NC State)
4. Alec McLachlan (St. John's, England)
5. Devin Armstrong (NJIT)
6. Andrew Cordes (North Carolina)
7. Holden Brown (Indiana)
8. Owen Cornell (UIC)
9. Tenzing Manske (Georgetown)
10. James Lowell (Marist)

One to Watch: Nigel Van Haveren. Van Haveren is easily one of the most explosive goalkeepers in the college game. For a level of competition that is so heavily focused on goalkeepers simply not making errors, Van Haveren has come out of the woodwork to show that goalkeepers can be more exciting than a tall, lumbering figure in net. Hailing from Vitesse Arnhem’s academy system, Van Haveren may be one of the rare international goalkeepers that MLS teams could look to bring in. American (and English, by proxy) will be annoyed at his complete disregard for sound mechanics but his ability to keep his team in a close game with a game-changing save is rare to find in college these days.

Juniors

1. Wyatt Nelson (UCLA)
2. Aidan Crawford (Loyola-Chicago)
3. Jonathan Munteanu (Dayton)
4. Rowan Schnebly (Stanford)
5. Ky Mani Dade (Loyola Marymount)
6. Thomas MacAuley (George Washington, England)
7. Soren Russell (SMU)
8. Zack Andoh (California)
9. Franco Barba (Eastern Illinois)
10. Isaiah Goldson (Michigan)

One to Watch: Wyatt Nelson. For a goalkeeper that probably should have left college by now, there doesn’t seem to be much slowing down Nelson’s trajectory. The 6’3” Seattle Sounders product has one of the more impressive resumes heading into college and he’s primed to take over the coveted starting spot for UCLA, marking him yet another USYNT goalkeeper for the Bruins. Although Nelson fulfills the safety blanket feeling most head coaches are desperately looking for, the college game inherently gets sloppier as the season rolls on and that’s not necessarily Nelson’s forte. If Nelson can find success when the play breaks down, his stock will only continue to skyrocket.

Sophomores

1. Blake Kelly (Notre Dame)
2. Leo Ledin (Virginia Tech, Sweden)
3. Pepe Hinterschuster (Wofford, Germany)
4. Marten Brink (Marquette, Germany)
5. Filip Versterre (South Carolina, Denmark)
6. Declan Finnegan (IUPUI)
7. Jonah Mednard (Wake Forest)
8. Matisse Hebert (Wisconsin, Canada)
9. Spencer Sanderson (Virginia)
10. Carlito Saylon (Tulsa)

One to Watch: Blake Kelly. RSL is known for producing a steady stream of, at the very least, college-ready goalkeepers and Kelly is the latest example. Kelly notched 12 starts for the Fighting Irish last fall before graduate student Collin Travasos finished the season, leaving a “what if” cloud hanging over the season. Moving forward, Kelly won’t have many opportunities to find a rhythm in the game, as Notre Dame’s defense historically does a decent job of negating shots. Now entering his sophomore year, most of Kelly’s defensive actions will likely lean a little more difficult than easy. If Kelly can embrace the sit-for-89-minutes-and-make-one-save mentality, look for Kelly to help bolster Notre Dame’s final four aspirations.

Freshmen

1. Joshua Grant (South Florida)
2. Patrick Los (Michigan)
3. Nick Bishop (Pittsburgh)
4. Alan Rutkowski (North Carolina)
5. Patryk Stechnij (Wisconsin)
6. Dylan Auffret (Penn)
7. Gavin Atkinson (Grand Canyon)
8. Owen Beninga (UC Santa Barbara)
9. Cole Kowalski (Notre Dame)
10. Dmytro Torubara (Georgetown)

One to Watch: Patrick Los. It’s been a while since we’ve had a 5’11” goalkeeper kick the door down in college but Los has as good a chance as anyone else that’s come before him. The Chicago Fire product was once touted as the next big thing when Slonina and Brady were garnering hype but the USYNT fanbase has largely cooled on him, despite his 37 professional appearances with Chicago Fire 2. Whether it was the lack of height or something else, Los has some doubters to prove wrong as he heads north. Keep an eye on the USYNT goalkeeper to see if he can unseat returning starter Isaiah Goldson or if he’ll have to play the waiting game like almost every other freshman.

Past Collegiate Goalkeeper Rankings

2024: Preseason
2023: Preseason and Final
2022: Preseason and Final
2021: Preseason and Final
2020: Preseason and Final
2019: Preseason and Final
2018: Preseason and Final
2017: Preseason and Final
2016: Preseason and Final
2015: Preseason and Final
2014: Preseason and Final

NCAA Women's Goalkeeper Rankings (Preseason Fall 2025)

Bill Reno August 6, 2025

Seniors

1. Teagan Wy (California)
2. Pauline Nelles (Arizona State, Germany)
3. Olivia Pratapas (NC State)
4. Keara Fitzgerald (Washington State)
5. Jordan Brown (Georgia)
6. Ally Lynch (Purdue)
7. Addy Holgorsen (Clemson)
8. Camryn Miller (Cincinnati)
9. Bella Hollenbach (Milwaukee)
10. Kamryn Willoughby (Eastern Washington)

11. Shea Vanderbosch (Syracuse)
12. Caroline Duffy (Oklahoma)
13. Ally Zazzara (Tennessee)
14. JLo Varada (Campbell, Puerto Rico)
15. Jordan Nytes (Colorado)
16. Cara Martin (Georgetown)
17. Sally Rainey (Indiana)
18. Cassie Coster (Monmouth)
19. Blythe Braun (Syracuse)
20. Belle Okoroafo (Michigan State)

One to Watch: Keara Fitzgerald. Fitzgerald enters the 2025 season with hopes of finishing her long and winding road on a positive note, while Washington State looks to recapture some of the magic in their 2019 Final Four run. State’s middling past few years paired with Fitzgerald returning from ACL surgery raise some questions on what to ultimately expect to see, as it’s a situation that can easily go sour if one or two things turn the wrong way. However, if Fitzgerald can stay healthy and return to form, she might not only be able to get State to regain their postseason magic, but she might also give herself a chance at playing at the next level.

Juniors

1. Victoria Safradin (Virginia)
2. Olivia Bodmer (Rutgers)
3. Kate Phillips (Missouri)
4. Maddie Buckley (UC Santa Barbara)
5. Izzy Lee (Illinois)
6. Leah Parsons (UAB, Canada)
7. Abby Gundry (North Carolina)
8. Kyla Holmes (Yale)
9. Morgan Hobbs (UNC Wilmington)
10. Allison Deardorff (Loyola-Chicago)

One to Watch: Olivia Bodmer. Of Rutgers’ 21 games last season, 15 were decided by a goal or less, highlighting the importance of Bodmer’s play. There were certainly some low points in the season, notably Bodmer’s failed clearance against Maryland or the unfortunate deflection off the post against UConn, but the Jersey-native wasn’t afraid to put her body on the line to keep her side in the fight, as she did countless times last fall. Bodmer teeters on the cusp of good or great, depending on how much nuance Bodmer can instill in her game moving forward. Look to see how the upperclassman has added detail in her game as Rutgers will surely lean heavily on their goalkeeper this fall.

Sophomores

1. Liv Geller (TCU)
2. Hannah Johann (North Carolina, Germany)
3. Sonoma Kasica (Notre Dame)
4. Sydney Fuller (Texas A&M)
5. Jamie Campbell (Colorado)
6. Addie Todd (Florida State)
7. Sarah Wommack (Mississippi State)
8. Genesis Perez Watson (UCF, Costa Rica)
9. Jillian Medvecky (Pepperdine)
10. Nona Reason (Clemson)
11. Mariangela Medina (UCLA, Mexico)
12. Kennadie Marchand (Vanderbilt)

One to Watch: Sarah Wommack. Wommack looks to pioneer the Appalachian State-to-Mississippi State transfer pipeline as the freshman shocked opposing coaches with her continual rebuffing of opposing offenses. Now in the SEC, Wommack will have to take on even more responsibility as State’s expectations are at an all-time high, coming off one of its best seasons ever. Wommack has been granted the number one jersey for a reason but for a program that’s looking to move beyond a Sweet Sixteen appearance, Wommack will need more than athleticism to bolster the Bulldogs’ chances in November. If Wommack can continue to extend her skill set beyond shot-stopping, look for the rocket on Wommack’s back to grow even larger.

Freshmen

1. Lexi Baldwin (Mississippi)
2. Evan O'Steen (Florida State)
3. Molly Vapensky (Duke)
4. Caroline Birkel (Stanford)
5. Zoe Anderson (UNC Wilmington)
6. Nyamma Nelson (Northwestern)
7. Jacqueline Gabbert (Minnesota)
8. Kennedy Zorn (Michigan State)
9. Wicki Dunlap (Virginia)
10. Kaele Smith (NJIT)

One to Watch: Evan O'Steen. Although TST headlines were rightfully filled with Hope Solo and Lindsey Harris, the young Florida State commit had an impressive showing in the summer tournament at just 17 years old. O’Steen was active in organizing the defense, cutting off slotted balls into the 18, and playing well off her line in order to help maintain possession for her team. The confident keeper did well in most areas of the field but close range situations saw her caught between two minds too often. Assuming the YNT goalkeeper will get a chance on the field this fall, look to see how O’Steen does on a larger stage and in a larger goal with one of the top schools in the nation this fall.

Past Collegiate Goalkeeper Rankings

2024: Preseason and Final
2023: Preseason and Final
2022: Preseason and Final
2021: Preseason and Final
2020: Preseason and Final
2019: Preseason and Final
2018: Preseason and Final
2017: Preseason and Final
2016: Preseason and Final
2015: Preseason and Final